Comments on Kaliope's WoW Crafting Blog: Neocrafting Part 3: Recipes

Good post in general but you contradict your self....

2009-10-13T06:42:51.086-07:00

Good post in general but you contradict your self. If grinding faction should be easy for players who can't group then so should getting recipes, there BoP dungeon recipes are not good.
How about token drops which could be traded - and drop in dungeons or as rare gathers / loot?
i kind of like how titanium powder works alongside the JC daily - though I think it should come from

i love that idea Rhom, i would love being able to ...

2009-09-26T22:09:33.226-07:00

i love that idea Rhom, i would love being able to choose different stats for an item AND a different look!

i also like the thought of making crafting a mini-game. it would be more enjoyable(and sometimes aggrivating) to actually craft items. the one problem i see with this right off is if you are trying to powerlevel, then you are sol lol
but then again, do mastercraftsmen (and

First I think this series you're doing is real...

2009-09-24T18:22:30.502-07:00

First I think this series you're doing is really great. It's been fun to think about all the options game designers could do and I really hope someone is brave enough to try and find out what works.

A couple of points about this installment in the series...

As for drops, I think the current system works out ok but could use some tweaking. You mentioned the extremely